Traditional clapboard home with a copper-roofed entry, bluestone steps, brick walk and autumn planting.

Pluckemin Lost Its Sandwich Counter the Same Month Bedminster's 1786 Tavern Got a New Name

The menu at Annie's Deli read like a guest list. The Fenwick was named for Congresswoman Millicent Fenwick. Valley Boys honored the staff of Valley Pharmacy. Dr. Jazz, a roast beef sandwich with horseradish cheese and Tiger sauce, was named by Jack Stine for himself, after one of his nicknames. These names come from the Mr. Local History Project's account of the deli, and the sandwiches outlasted three changes of ownership.

The counter at 2095 Burnt Mills Road served its last sandwich on Saturday, October 24. Patch reported that the deli said it was forced to close "due to new fire codes and the age of our building."

Fifteen days earlier, a building more than 200 years older reopened on Bedminster's Main Street with new owners, a new chef and a new name. In both cases, the building decided what happened next. And Bedminster's next everyday lunch spot will be built from the ground up on an office campus along Route 206.

A 40-year counter in a rented 1820s building

Annie's began somewhere else under another name. The Mr. Local History Project says Emily Beer Stine started the Burnt Mills Deli in 1983 at the counter of her father's Colonial Liquors in Pluckemin. The name comes from the colonial milling community along the Lamington River whose mills burned sometime between 1781 and 1807.

Stine sold the business to Diane Calabrese, who moved it into a rented 1820s building behind the liquor store. According to the same account, the deli still rented that building when it closed.

Around 1987, Annie became the third owner. She renamed the deli for herself, added sandwiches of her own and kept Stine's originals. After a short stretch under Mike and Bob Bashahd, Roman and Nick Hnidj bought the deli in 1994. They had run a bakery before, which is where the homemade cookies, desserts and salads came from. Nick retired in 2009, and Roman and Patty kept the counter going. Through every one of those owners, the sandwich menu barely changed.

The business passed through four sets of hands and stayed put. The thing that finally gave out was the building it rented. The farewell posted by the deli, as quoted by Patch, talked about the people who came through the door:

"While our hearts are heavy saying goodbye, they are even fuller because of the incredible community that has supported us along the way. You made this place more than a business. You made it a home."

The tavern that kept its walls and changed nearly everything else

The building at Main Street and Hillside Avenue opened in 1786, when Bedminster village was still called Lesser Crossroads. New Jersey Hills reported that the former Delicious Heights reopened as The Bedminster Tavern with a dinner service on Friday, October 9, after closing for just four days of renovations.

Four days is a short turnaround. New Jersey Hills says the bar and restaurant areas of the 240-year-old building are largely the same. The servers and bartenders stayed on. The visible changes were deliberate:

  • A service area at the entrance to the bar was taken out, and a piano now stands in its place.
  • The room once known as Legends Sports Bar, which in recent years hosted only private parties, is becoming a whisky bar called Stables, and the tavern's own site now features The Stables for cocktails, whiskey and wine.
  • The decor is shifting toward an equestrian look.

The new owner, Alyssa Cranston, knows the room well. Patch reported that she started at Delicious Heights at 16 as a greeter and server, then worked her way up while also serving as catering sales manager at the Bridgewater Manor. In the same article she described the menu change: "We wanted to get away from more of the fried bar food and get more into things that made sense for Somerset County."

The kitchen now has a chef with a fine-dining background. New Jersey Hills reports that Christopher Albrecht was lead chef at the Ryland Inn in Whitehouse Station for the past eight years, and before that cooked at Eno Terra in Kingston. He plans to build dishes around New Jersey vegetables and farm-to-fork ingredients from local farms. Cranston works with The Celtic Hospitality Group, a new Bridgewater company led by chief executive Thomas J. McAteer, who used to be general manager of the Ryland Inn. "Our goal is to be the heart of Bedminster," McAteer told the paper.

The tavern's official site lists weekend brunch and live music. That gives Main Street a sit-down weekend option, but it doesn't take over the 7 a.m. breakfast sandwich or the office catering tray that Annie's handled in Pluckemin.

Where the weekday deli run goes now

The routine Annie's covered is still around. It's just spread across more places, mostly on the Route 202/206 corridor and in Pluckemin. Each of these counters lists the basics on its own pages:

Counter Address What it lists Posted hours
Steck's North Deli 75 Washington Valley Road, Pluckemin Breakfast sandwiches, deli lunch, catering 6 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Saturday; 8 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. Sunday
Lil' Pickles Bagel & Deli 318 US-202, Bedminster Bagel sandwiches, breakfast and deli platters, catering 6 a.m. to 2 p.m. weekdays; 6 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. weekends
Kings deli and bakery 450 Hills Drive, Bedminster Sandwiches, wraps, soups, party trays, bagels and baked goods 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily
Bedminster Pizza 2480 Lamington Road Sandwiches, Italian food, catering 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday and Sunday; to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday; closed Monday
Dunkin' 1525 Route 206, at the Shell station Coffee, breakfast sandwiches 5 a.m. to 8:45 p.m. daily

Dunkin' also has a second Bedminster location at 1109 Route 202/206.

Steck's is the closest match to the Pluckemin breakfast-and-lunch counter, with weekday hours that start at 6 a.m. Lil' Pickles opens just as early but closes by mid-afternoon. Kings is the one that stays open late. Posted hours can change with the season, so check with Steck's and Bedminster Pizza directly before planning a catering pickup around them.

The next counter is being built from scratch on Route 206

Bedminster's next new casual food space won't go into an old building. Real Estate NJ reported on October 13 that Advance Realty Investors has started construction on Bedminster Village Square: four buildings totaling 19,240 square feet at 1420 Route 206, at the signalized intersection with Advance Drive. Advance is targeting a 2027 opening.

According to NJ.com, the first two buildings will each be about 5,770 square feet, set around a central courtyard with outdoor seating. The other two will each be about 3,850 square feet, with patios attached. Leasing is aimed at food and beverage businesses, medical and physical therapy providers, boutique fitness and wellness concepts, and other services. Robert Mackowski of Pierson Commercial Real Estate is leading the leasing.

The site already has a weekday lunch crowd built in. NJ.com reports that Freshpet opened a 30,000-square-foot global headquarters on the same campus after moving from Secaucus. When Freshpet broke ground in July 2024, MyCentralJersey reported that about 100 employees were expected there. Advance investment chief Alex Cocoziello told Real Estate NJ that the retail, dining and services are meant to create a walkable mixed-use setting. Later plans described by MyCentralJersey also include pedestrian connections to the township's trail and open-space network.

Until then, the Village Square courtyard is a construction site at the Advance Drive signal, aiming to open in 2027.

Before the courtyard, a candle in River Road Park

The rest of this season's calendar still runs through Bedminster's older buildings. The Jacobus Vanderveer House begins its Colonial Christmas with a free tree lighting on Friday, November 27, from 5 to 7 p.m. at River Road Park, 3055 River Road. The house lists hot drinks, a candle program, music and Santa. Open houses follow on Saturday, November 28, and Sunday, November 29, from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. Saturday includes a Clydesdale ride and holiday shopping. Sunday brings a chorus, re-enactors and a gingerbread-house workshop.

If you're planning a holiday gathering and want to know which Pluckemin and Bedminster counters still fill catering trays, or you just want to trade Annie's stories over coffee, Brown & McCrea would be glad to hear from you. Lunch recommendations come with the job.

Let's Find Your Dream Home

We pride ourselves on providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact us today to discuss all your real estate needs!

Follow Us on Instagram